Method

How scores work

Each city gets two scores, and we never blend them into one number: the Safety Score and the TribeScore. Every number below is the one the site uses. Where we lack enough data, a city shows “Insufficient verified data” and no score.

TribeScore: Jewish community

How much Jewish life a city has, from 0 to 100. It is a weighted average of the inputs below, each put on a 0 to 1 scale first.

InputWeightScale
Jewish population40 of 1000 at 1,000 people or fewer, full marks at 2,000,000 or more, on a log scale
Synagogues25 of 1000 at none, full marks at 600 or more, on a log scale
Kosher food20 of 1000 at none, full marks at 300 or more, on a log scale
Jewish schools10 of 1000 at none, full marks at 100 or more, on a log scale
Mikvah and Chabad5 of 1000 at none, full marks at 50 or more, on a log scale

A missing input is left out and its weight is shared among the inputs we have; we never fill it in. A city needs a jewish population figure and at least 2 other inputs. Counts of places come from the lists on each city page, with their sources and the date we checked them.

Safety Score: reported antisemitic events

How the antisemitic events reported in a city recently compare with what is normal for that city. It is not a crime rate and it is not safety advice.

Which events count

Events we have collected from news reports and grouped into one entry each (see the feed). Each type has a weight:

Event typeWeight
Assault5
Attack or plot5
Threat or harassment2
Vandalism2
Campus or institutional1

Recent against normal

  1. Recent: the weighted events of the last 56 days (8 weeks). An event counts less as it ages: half its weight after 21 days.
  2. Normal: the same city's weighted events from day 57 to day 420 back (or as far back as our record is complete), turned into what the recent figure would read at that steady rate.
  3. Ratio: (recent + 5) ÷ (normal + 5). Adding 5 to both sides stops one or two events in a quiet city from swinging the score.
  4. Small cities lean on their country: the city's own ratio counts n ÷ (n + 12), where n is its number of events in the normal period; the rest comes from the same ratio for the whole country. A city whose score is mostly its country's says so.
  5. Score: 70 − 20 × log₂(ratio), kept between 5 and 95. 70 means about normal; each doubling of the recent rate takes 20 points off, each halving adds 20.
ScoreLabel
80–95Quieter than usual
60–79Normal for here
40–59Elevated
5–39High

The arrow beside a score is its change over the last 4 weeks.

When there is no Safety Score

  • Our event record has fewer than 12 complete weeks.
  • The country has fewer than 20 events in the normal period, so there is nothing steady to lean on.
  • Cities in Israel: Israeli cities show TribeScore only.

Compared only within a country

Each score measures a city against its own normal, and reporting differs a great deal between countries. So we only rank cities on safety against other cities in the same country.

Honest limits

  • Events come from what the press reports. Places that are under-reported can look quieter than they are.
  • An event marked News report has not yet been checked by a person; ✓ Verified means one of our team has.
  • Place counts are the places we could verify in the sources we checked. Where a source stops listing past a limit, the count is shown as a minimum.

Browse the cities See the feed